State of the Project, End of 2025

library shelves featuring a series of old (at least partly non-english) illustrated encyclopedia in poor-to-mid condiition, with old Dewey Decimal (I think?) stickers on the spines.

Greetings, dear reader! I’m overdue on my monthly check-in, I know. Since I last wrote, things have been interesting on a local level as well as Interesting on a national one. My youngest stepson somewhat abruptly moved in with us full time, which while lovely has been a somewhat unplanned bandwidth expenditure that required a lot of reallocation of time, money, and attention. In addition, Christmas and all things end of year have put quite a few things in the slow column, regrettably including the LBP.

That being said, I have at least put a few hours in on it since November’s check-in. I’m still working on “L”, but I’ve at least gotten through the Library of Congress. I’ll give a fuller accounting later in January, but I thought for now I’d give something of an overview, both of last year’s work and the project to date.

In March 2022, I started building this website and recording data in earnest, beginning with an effort to find where the books were I’d need to see and what sort of travel might be needed. I expected this to take a few months (Oh, sweet, nรคive past-me!). By January 2023, I began to realize I’d been in error and this would be a longer process, due in part to the Memoirs of the Duke of Sully, in all its translations.

In July 2023, I finished with Phase 1 of the project, which was gathering data on all extant copies of Lennox’s work and trying to get some sort of sense of where things were. In the end, I created a total of 3 custom Google maps of locations, broken down by title, then year and bookseller/location. I would have preferred to have all the locations in one file, but I hit the limits of what custom Google maps could handle each time and had to open a new one.

I next had to verify holdings and make sure my notes were accurate as Phase 2, which meant going through each library’s catalogue and making sure all the listings were for physical books, not e-books or ECCO subscriptions or microfiche/microfilm. I pulled the data into CSV formats and put it into one large spreadsheet, then organized it by library rather than book title. From there, I began the process of verifying items in hopes of cleaning up the data and getting to the more active research of Phase 3 — a process that is still ongoing. At the end of Phase 2.1, I had 2612 prospective records, which I thought was a lot. ๐Ÿ™‚ I also started a Heurist database to use as the eventual backbone of of the data, and possibly the eventual functionality for the bibliography. We’ll have to see.

I began Phase 2.2 that month, with my first update in August 2023. I am still doing that work, going more or less alphabetically by library name. If the number of records holds anything like true (I suspect it’s closer to 3000) then I’m a bit over halfway through, roughly 18 months later. According to the last full update in October 2025, I hit 1156 records confirmed, not counting those I’d deleted as duplicates or that didn’t turn out to exist. There’s still a lot of eventual math to be done, but I’d say overall I am pleased with the progress I’m making.

I think it’ll be at least another year until I start applying for research fellowships for in-person work, though I will probably start pursuing some smaller opportunities to help fund a Heurist subscription. It’s free, but if I’m going to be using it more often, I should contribute to the org’s costs.

I knew this would be a long term project. I don’t know if I had entirely reckoned on coming up on four years without seriously being able to look at actual books yet. That being said, I’m not tired of it yet, and I think I’ve actually uncovered some interesting insights. Here’s to continued progress. I’ll be posting an actual update in a couple weeks’ time.

State of the Project, November 2025

Or; why does our author ever expect to get anything but grading done in the last quarter of the semester, a tale of Great Expectations but Very Little Actual Progress. offered for the Public Good and General Scholarly Edification

A Victorian illustration of a wild turkey walking in a rural landscape, with three baby turkeys grazing at its feet.
Wild Turkey, Game Birds series by themet is licensed under CC-CC0 1.0

Much as I wish I had progress to report, I have none — this is the season of Writing Feedback, and I am up to my eyeballs in thesis statements and argumentation, or at least attempts at these things. December should be much more fruitful. In the meantime, to all my readers and friends, happy USA Thanksgiving and holiday season ahead.

State of the Project, July 2025

A block print of the capital letter G, with two skeletons dragging away a struggling queen behind the letter, presumably reinforcing the inescapability of death.
Letter G (c. 1523) Hans by National Gallery of Art is licensed under CC-CC0 1.0

Greetings, gentle reader! I’m not 100% sure what’s happening in the background of the letter G, but clearly she is not escaping death despite her status. A lesson for tyrants everywhere, methinks. But on sunnier thoughts, I completed the letter G!

Things I learned from G:

  • I should not have been surprised at how many institutional libraries are named after people named George, and yet here we are.
  • I will also need to spend some time in Germany, because as Norbert Schurer noted, the Germans were seriously fans of Lennox and published possibly the most translations/non-British editions of her work of any country, during her lifetime at least. There are also multiple German editions of her plays, which is really exciting.
  • Most unusual libraries on the list: the Tyron Palace library in North Carolina, and Gladstone’s library in the UK. Like, I am so excited to make that trip! And the volume they have is one of her harder works to find — her translation of Meditations and Penitent Prayers by the Duchess de la Valliere.

I have no reason to suspect that I will keep up this streak and finish H in August, though I will make progress. For one, I’ve got gallbladder surgery scheduled for the first week in August, and other than that, it’s the run up to the semester. Also, H has a lot going on with it — some big collections in there.

Number of libraries confirmed: 207
Number of libraries entered into the database: 2
Number of extant copies confirmed: 746

State of the Project, June 2025

Greetings, gentle reader! The heat dome is upon us, and it sucks a whole lot, but I am pleased to announce that I have finished the letter F!

Things I learned from F:

  • I’m going to need to spend at least a month in France one of these summers. The National Library of France has so many editions and translations that I just don’t easily have access to here in the US.
  • The Fondren library at Rice, the Folger, and Princeton’s libraries are all must visits (Princeton is in this section because of listings in the Firestone library, which leads into the next point).
  • I’ve finally come to the conclusion that, because my info about which books are where within an institution with multiple libraries is a bit suspect, I really need to just group institutional holdings together, with rare exceptions (such as the Lewis Walpole Library and the Beinecke). So I’m finding separate sections I have for an institution and pulling them together, since they’re usually in the same catalog. This also went for the Five Colleges consortium, since they all share the same library catalog system.

The good news is that G is going to be short. H, however, is going to take quite a while given the Harry Ransom Library and the Houghton, for examples. In the meantime, I have been trying to pick out the readings I checked out of the library. I’m starting to sort of coalesce on an idea for moving forward, but I’m not entirely there yet.

Number of libraries confirmed: 184
Number of libraries entered into the database: 2
Number of extant copies confirmed: 688

State of the Project, May 2025

Pink-purple flowering tree branches with sparse green leaves, all against a brilliant blue sky

Greetings, friends! It has been an eventful spring, what with *gestures at the entire landscape of the United States* all this going on. Also, in April, with two weeks of the semester left, I managed to get sick and break a rib from coughing. I am well and recovering, but I certainly can’t recommend the experience. That being said, I am making progress again! I have finished with the letter “E,” which feels like forward momentum.

Things I have learned from E: First (still, again), my initial forays into WorldCat feel as though when there were multiple libraries at an institution, they simply picked one out of the bunch and assigned it to that one if not otherwise specified. Now, some of this could be that my data set is a little older, and things do get moved around — into and out of storage, deaccessioned, whatever. But the sheer number of entries that are elsewhere (for example, holdings listed at various NYPL branches rather than at the Schwartzman location, which is apparently where most all this stuff I’m looking for actually lives) is too high to be altogether attributable to changes over time.

Second (and this is more of a personal pet peeve), the number of entries that suggest Johnson did the actual writing/translation for Lennox is more pervasive than I’d really realized and also deeply annoying. I have a great admiration for Samuel Johnson, but he frankly didn’t have the bandwidth to have written the better part of Lennox’s work in addition to his own, even if we ignore issues of style, content, and consistency. One more thing to work on, I suppose.

Third, I need to get busy determining what info I really want and how I’m going to present it. I’m doing more reading this summer on descriptive bibliography in general and trying to build up my library so I can make informed choices. We’ll see what we can find. I’ll keep the blog updated as I make decisions, naturally.

Number of libraries confirmed: 165
Number of libraries entered into the database: 2
Number of extant copies confirmed: 554

State of the Project, January 2025

A large initial letter D entwined with and surrounded by garlands, black ink on an ivory background
Initial letter D with garlands by The Metropolitan Museum of Art is licensed under CC-CC0 1.0

Happy New Year! After a break that took me through the last quarter of last year, I am back pushing at my data verification boulder once more. As you might be able to tell from the image above, I am finished with the letter D. D contains 100 verified entries, which I mention primarily because it’s such a conveniently round number. Particular highlights include the UNC-Chapel Hill Davis library, the Detroit Public Library, Duke University library, UCSB and UC-Berkeley, The Royal Danish Library, and (unexpectedly for me) The Biblioteca de Catalyuna in Barcelona, Spain.*

Number of Libraries Confirmed: 149
Number of Libraries Entered into the Database: 2
Number of Extant Copies Confirmed: 618

*Do note that when we’re talking large library systems, often times the library I wrote down initially is not where the thing is actually housed, or it’s in special collections inside the library at large, or it’s off in storage somewhere, so for now this bit of data is still slightly wibbly. The existence of the books is confirmed, though, and that’s the important thing.

State of the Project, October 2024

Hello, friends. My apologies for the short note here (and for missing September entirely). Between dodging burnout and having Covid for the first time, this project has been temporarily back-burnered. I expect that by the end of the year I’ll be working on it again with a bit more oomph, but I frankly needed the break. I have progressed a bit on “D” but I haven’t finished the letter yet. For November I’ll post statistics again and get things moving, but for now I just wanted to touch base and note that I haven’t abandoned the project or forgotten to update. I’ve just been a bit snowed under, and I’m looking forward to that letting up. Good thoughts, friends.

State of the Project, Holiday Season 2023

Photo by Dana Tentis on Pexels.com

Happy holidays, gentle readers! I hope this season finds you reasonably well, at least on a local level, given the general setting of GAAAAAH globally at the moment. I myself have been digging deep into work and family and friendship as a sustaining focus for the past two months, hence the lack of distinct November update.

I had the good(?) news that I’m teaching both an extra class in the spring and a class online in the summer (assuming it fills), which on the one hand, yay! My car approves this decision. On the other hand, prep and grading and whatnot have largely eaten my ability to focus on Lennox work, so I’ve decided to let this lie fallow for the holiday season while I work on clearing my plate for the coming year. In January, therefore, I’ll be picking back up with the project work as normal. I hope to have new progress to update next time around.

For now, however, I hope that whatever you celebrate, you are able to take a moment to yourself and acknowledge the dark and light, the turning of the year and the brightness inherent in the human spirit even when things seem hopeless. May we all have a brighter 2024.

State of the Project, September 2023

Greetings, gentle readers! September finds me pushing forward still, albeit a bit more slowly due to general life issues and a lot of time dedicated to sorting through the works housed at the Beinecke Rare Book and Manuscript Library at Yale. Needless to say, we’re going to have to spend some time there in the future, to no one’s surprise.

I currently have 30 libraries verified, having removed two or three so far that ostensibly had only a couple of items at most, and they turned out to either simply not be there, to belong to an affiliated library on the same system, or to be online or microfom versions of the work. I am looking at applying to the Lewis Walpole Library Fellowship this year, along with perhaps a local fellowship that might cover some gas money for libraries near to hand.

Number of libraries confirmed: 34
Number of libraries entered into the database: 2
Number of extant copies confirmed: 148

State of the Project, August 2023

Photo by Luis Zheji on Pexels.com

Greetings, gentle readers! The end of Hot Data Summer is upon us, and I have nearly finished all my class prep for the next semester’s teaching. Around and among and before that, I’ve been busily embarking on Phase 2.2 of the project, which as stated in July’s update, involves breaking out the data by library/institution (it depends on the nature of the organization and its libraries — there’s a system, I promise) and verifying holdings via catalog searches and/or contacting the library directly in some cases.

Thus far I’ve completed a mere twenty libraries, but that’s still served to provide some interesting insights. I have eliminated some prospective holdings (either they don’t exist or were online access only), but I’ve uncovered at least as many that simply weren’t in ESTC or Worldcat when I used it, for whatever reason. I knew there would be missed volumes, so that isn’t that surprising, but the number and type of them is still intriguing. As an example, an early data point (we’ll see if it holds) is that out of those 20, six libraries have multiple pre-1850 editions of the Memoirs of the Duke of Sully. What does that mean? I’m not sure, but it’s something to ponder and look into further if it holds up.

As far as the database design goes, I’ve put it aside for the moment. I could, in theory, enter holdings in as I confirm them (almost certainly a good idea, now that I think about it) but I would like to get a bit more done in confirmation first, and then perhaps have phases of entering data as opposed to a more constant back and forth.

Number of libraries confirmed: 20
Number of libraries entered into the database: 2
Number of extant copies confirmed: 77